Loading...
2021-03-09 CC Meeting MinutesMOUND CITY COUNCIL MINUTES March 9, 2021 The City Council of the City of Mound, Hennepin County, Minnesota, met in regular session on Tuesday, March 9, 2021 at 7:00 p.m. in the Westonka Schools Performing Arts Center in Minnetrista. Members present: Mayor Ray Salazar; Council Members Phil Velsor, Paula Larson, Sherrie Pugh, and Jason Holt Members absent: None Others present: City Manager Eric Hoversten, Community Development Director Sarah Smith, Administrative Services Coordinator Kevin Kelly, City Engineer Brian Simmons, Terry & Linda Olson, Emily Colestock, Rodney Beystrom, Veronica Anderson, Jeff Prieve, Mark McGlinsky, Steve Lynch, Liz Vandam, Betsy & Greg Hedding, Jason & Tirisha Dirks, Eric Schmidt, Douglas Williams, Margo Williams, Jackie Piepkorn, Sam Erickson, Johan Chemin, Brian & Kathleen Olesinksi, Betsy Grady, Danielle Rousselange, Dane Vocelka, Tim Lee, Kaila Hage, Kelly Jaworksi, Paul Levin, Irene Knott, Scott Gregory, Karla Johnston, Troy Jordan, David Holl, Katie Holt, Drew Vocelka, David Lambert, Sam Steadman, Christine Lambert, Justin Dale and PJ McDead. Consent agenda: All items listed under the Consent Agenda are considered to be routine in nature by the Council. There will be no separate discussion on these items unless a Councilmember or citizen so requests, in which event it will be removed from the Consent Agenda and considered in normal sequence. 1. Open meeting Mayor Salazar called the meeting to order at 7:02 p.m. 2 Pledae of Allegiance 3. Approve agenda Larson requested Item 4E be pulled from the consent agenda for discussion. Hoversten noted amendments to the agenda include new Item 5.1 — requested action on a Resolution of sponsorship as related to the Westonka Historical Society, and additional comments for Item 7a.; Proposed tattoo studio. MOTION by Velsor, seconded by Pugh, to approve the amended agenda as amended. All voted in favor. Motion carried. 4. Consent agenda MOTION by Larson, seconded by Holt, to approve the consent agenda as amended. Upon roll call vote, all voted in favor. Motion carried. A. Approve payment of claims at 3-12-21 meeting B. Approve minutes: 2-23-21 regular meeting C. Approve Pay Request #3 and Final in the amount of $17,315.92 to Widmer Mound City Council Minutes — March 9, 2021 Construction for the 2019 Fernside Forcemain Improvement & Bay Ridge Sewer Service City Project PW-19-03 & 09 D. Approve Pay Request #2 in the amount of $207,352.03 to Metropolitan Council Environmental Services for the 2018 Street, Utility, and Retaining Wall Improvements — Westedge Blvd, PW-18-01 E. Pulled 4E. (Pulled) Approve Resolution 21- Amending Resolution No. 19-80 that approved vacations in Mound Harbor District (Planning Case No. 19-06) Larson asked for clarification on item 4. E, the Mound Harbor vacation resolution. Smith stated this item is a housekeeping matter with Hennepin County in order to clarify the description of easements and uses vacated under the original Resolution. MOTION by Larson, seconded by Holt, to approve the following resolution. All voted in favor. Motion carried. RESOLUTION NO. 21-23: RESOLUTION AMENDING RESOLUTION NO. 19-80 THAT APPROVED VACATIONS IN MOUND HARBOR DISTRICT PLANNING CASE NO. 19-06 5. Comments and suggestions from citizens present on any item not on the agenda. Johan Chemin, 6039 Beachwood Road, requested that all meeting attendees follow the mask wearing mandate and be respectful to everyone. Doug Williams, 5479 Lost Lake Lane, stated he wanted to address Item 7 on the agenda. 5.1 (added) Liz Vandam on behalf of Westonka Historical Society requesting action on a Resolution of Sponsorship as Related to the Westonka Historical Society Vandam said this resolution would allow the Westonka Historical Society (WHS) to further and more broadly pursue State grant funding for museum improvements. Vandam stated she is a volunteer at the WHS which curates the history and culture of the communities of Spring Park, Minnetonka Beach, Navarre, Orono, Minnetrista and Mound. Vandam said the WHS entered into a discussion on the potential co -location of WHS and the Westonka Hennepin County Public Library in Mound. Vandam is seeking City sponsorship to secure funds, and, if awarded, to be named the bonded recipient agent for those funds. MOTION by Pugh, seconded by Holt, to approve the following resolution. All voted in favor. Motion carried. RESOLUTION NO. 21-24: RESOLUTION OF SPONSORSHIP AS RELATED TO THE WESTONKA HISTORICAL SOCIETY 6. Orono Police Sergeant Tim Sonnek presenting the Mound activity report for February Hoversten stated Sergeant Sonnek was not able to be present at the meeting and will be asked back at the next Council meeting in March. 7. Planning Commission Recommendation A. Consideration of request for evaluation of tattoo studio as substantially similar use at Mound City Council Minutes — March 9, 2021 5439 Shoreline Drive in Lost Lake commercial building as provided by City Code Sec. 129-71 Applicant: Dane Vocelka Owner: Samuel C. & Shea F. Steadman Smith presented an overview of the applicant Dane Vocelka's request for a Substantially Similar Use Determination to allow for the operation of a tattoo studio business at the Lost Lake commercial building which also holds Caribou Coffee. Smith noted the packet includes additional comments from Steve Johnson of the Lost Lake Villas Home Owners Association (HOA) for the Council's executive consideration of the matter. Smith stated the Planning Commission has reviewed the application materials from Vocelka and has reviewed the zoning code land use table to determine the use of a tattoo studio is substantially similar to retail sales and service which are allowed uses. Smith added that the property owned by the Steadmans currently houses the Caribou Coffee Shop and a dry cleaner business. Smith said the location of the proposed tattoo studio is in the western portion of the building which has held a Chiropractic business and a health boutique retail business. Smith stated tattoo businesses are licensed by Hennepin County. Smith added that staff feel the use is appropriate and substantially similar to over the counter retail business activity. Smith added the Planning Commission approved the use at the February 2nd meeting and concludes that the tattoo studio is similar in use to those allowed in the Pedestrian PUD district. Smith said the Planning Commission agreed that the tattoo studio is a permissible retail sale and service use and is similar to a nail salon as the proposed business is a small in scope tattoo studio. Smith said the business will have only three or four employees and will be a retail store which will also sell art supplies and custom fishing guide services. Smith noted there is no requirement for a public hearing on this matter but did mail a notice to neighbors as a courtesy. Smith said the packet includes the draft resolution with staff and Planning Commission recommendations and noted the 60-day agency land use approval/denial clock is nearing its end. Dane Vocelka, 236 25th Street SE of Buffalo, Minnesota, addressed the Council by stating he is an ambitious business man who will strive to keep the business small and private. Vocelka said he has lived on Wilshire Blvd. in Mound previously and the space is a great fit for him and he would love to work with everyone in the community. Vocelka said in addition to the tattoo studio his business would offer services to professional' artists and also fishing guide services. Vocelka added he would keep the exterior of the building professional and tasteful. Pugh asked Vocelka what kind of traffic would the business add to the coffee shop area and how many clients per day would he work with. Vocelka said a typical work day would include one or two clients. Vocelka added that due to the Governor's Executive Order only one customer could be present with no more than two artists at a time. Vocelka said client information is exchanged through phone calls or remote email consultations and he added he liked to be home with his family at night. Doug Williams addressed the Council by stating he didn't get enough advance notice of the meeting to prepare comments. Velsor stated the HOA was informed about the meeting so why did they submit input to the agenda so late in the process. Williams said he was traveling at the time and didn't have the access to visit with HOA members. Mound City Council Minutes — March 9, 2021 Doug Williams stated he is the President of the Lost Lake Villas HOA and lives at 5479 Lost Lake Lane. Williams said the HOA Board called an emergency meeting to declare unanimous opposition to the tattoo studio and would like to delay a decision of the Council as the HOA believes the tattoo studio is not substantially similar to other allowed uses and that tattoo businesses are regulated in the Adult Business portion of the City Code and should not be located within 200 feet of a residence. Williams said at least seven residences are within 200 feet and the first thing you would see when entering the Villas is a tattoo parlor. Williams added the business is literally within 83 feet of our backyard. Velsor asked Williams what other uses Williams ascribes to the tattoo studio. Williams answered it is equivalent to massage parlors and suggested another location for the business within the City. Velsor asked Williams what he thinks the problem is going to be with the tattoo studio and Williams stated that their real estate investment value will decrease and the HOA members are primary investors in the Lost Lake Harbor area. Velsor and Holt both stated the proposed tattoo studio is not a derogatory business but it is good to have a community discussion to allow input. Williams said tattoo parlors are regulated by the state as an adult service and that Vocelka's tattoo business has been rejected by other business properties in town. Williams added that the City Lost Lake slips can't be used to conduct business such as bringing in fishing boats. Williams said the Caribou Coffee already attracts boat trailers to the area and customers are parking in private areas of the HOA property. Williams again requested to table decision to the next Council meeting. Salazar asked for a continuance to the March 23`d meeting. Salazar stated that it is only fair to hear their disagreements. Larson said she is in agreement to wait until the next meeting and Velsor said this will give Vocelka time to prepare as well. Pugh agreed to table the discussion and said the HOA should meet with the business owner. Holt said the Planning Commission heard Vocelka speak and wished he would have done more of the same pitch at this Council meeting. Holt said there have been three different businesses within the same space at the building and he wants to see a respectable business. Holt said one of the former businesses in the same space was a CBD retail store which he considers a similar business to the tattoo studio. Salazar added the tattoo industry has vastly changed over the years and people are getting tattoos for many reasons including honoring loved ones and it is not the Council's decision to determine if tattoos are good or bad. Salazar would like to give the HOA time to respond and prepare an argument and also allow Vocelka an additional opportunity to speak. MOTION by Larson, seconded by Pugh, to continue the agenda item to the next Council Meeting, All voted in favor. Motion carried. Mound City Council Minutes — March 9, 2021 8. City Engineer Brian Simmons presenting on City Water System and Water Quality Brian Simmons, City Engineer, Bolton and Menk, presented to the Council "The State of Our Water." Simmons said the main goals of the City in regards to water service are to be reliable, affordable and safe. Simmons gave an overview of the water distribution system of the City. Simmons said there are currently two active wells, two towers and 48.5 miles of distribution pipes which were installed in the 1950-60's and have been either rebuilt or rehabbed since then. Simmons added the City has been making improvements to the City water system since 2007 to improve water flow throughout the system but especially to the Island which now has three water connections versus one when the improvements began. Simmons said the improvements have produced better water flow which assists fire protection services as well. Simmons said these long-term commitments made by the City to improve infrastructure, service and supply has affected water rates as increases were used to fund the improvements. Simmons said another duty of the City is to provide safe water to residents and to treat and test the water supply at required intervals and report findings to the State. Simmons said those reports include testing for lead and copper content and the chlorine and fluoride treatment to the water supply. Simmons said there is iron and manganese which is naturally in the aquafer and causes the discoloration of the water in some homes in Mound. Simmons stated that testing for manganese has recently begun to be required by the State and in December testing revealed that City wells number 3 and 8 were found in to be above standards and in subsequent January and February resampling found elevated levels of manganese. Simmons said the Minnesota Department of Health has determined through scientific research that manganese exposure over long periods of time can have negative health effects. Simmons added that manganese is not regulated presently but the State made the recommendation to the City to communicate the manganese issue to water users and offer solutions to mitigate those effects. Simmons said the State recommendations are the use of home water filters and the use of bottled water for infants. Simmons said the long-term treatment of the problem can be addressed through home treatment such as reverse osmosis filters or at the source by municipal treatment. The treatment options would also remove iron which contributes to water discoloration. Simmons listed the Cost and Treatment options facing the City: • Reverse osmosis home treatment finished by residents - $250-2,000 • Centralized Treatment plant — $40-50 Million • City construction of two filtration plants to remove iron and manganese $12-18 Million at a $250-270 rate increase per year for construction alone • Lime softening plants remove iron/manganese and water hardness - $22-36 Million This requires a large footprint and increases of $550-600 per year in water rates for construction alone • Iron and manganese sequestering — reduces some rusty water but does not remove iron or manganese at $150-250K which loses effectiveness with age of system • Continue testing and monitoring manganese levels which the City is not required to do Mound City Council Minutes — March 9, 2021 Simmons presented potential funding source options which including using water rates, applying for state funding sources and Minnesota Public Facilities Authority clean drinking water revolving fund. Pugh asked if the City could be eligible to receive more than one type of financing. Simmons said yes and there are other options which include low interest loans and direct legislative funding. Holt asked about language in the Resolution which mentioned the manganese exceeding the health advisory level but it has not established the long term health effects. Simmons said the long term effects are being studied but the home owner can now use a home water filter which is effective against manganese. Hoversten said the notice to residents will have very similar language and context to the DOH advisories. Salazar said the increase in water rates was the City response to repair and replace worn out delivery pipes. Salazar added that cities with newer developments don't have infrastructure which has aged into the need for repair. Salazar said modernization adds cost to residents and the City needs to take care of problem before the City is mandated to do the work. Salazar stated a feasibility study is the first step to study this problem. Hoversten said the need to have safe water will put the affordable aspect in jeopardy and the City will try to get in line to be ready to get infrastructure dollars from federal or state sources. Hoversten said the funding will come from outside sources and/or City water rates or through the use of resident filtering and finishing water in their home. Hoversten said the discoloration nuisance might also be addressed by the work to eliminate excess manganese. A. Action to approve a Resolution directing Engineering Staff to Notify Residents and Municipal Water Customers of the Presence of Manganese in the City Water that Exceeds the Minnesota Department of Health Advisory Limit MOTION by Velsor, seconded by Holt, to approve the following resolution. All voted in favor. Motion carried. RESOLUTION NO. 21-25: RESOLUTION DIRECTING ENGINEERING STAFF TO NOTIFY RESIDENTS AND MUNCIPAL WATER CUSTOMERS OF THE PRESENCE OF MANGANESE IN CITY WATER THAT EXCEEDS THE MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH ADVISORY LIMIT B. Action to approve a Resolution Ordering Preparation of Report on Water Treatment Facilities MOTION by Larson, seconded by Pugh, to approve the following resolution. All voted in favor. Motion carried. RESOLUTION NO. 21-26: RESOLUTION ORDERING PREPARATION OF REPORT ON WATER TREATMENT FACILITIES Larson asked about the time line on the study which Simmons said it would take two to three months to prepare the project priority plan so the City will be in line for the outside source funding cycles later in the year. Mound City Council Minutes — March 9, 2021 The Council took comments from the audience Johan Chemin asked where the iron was coming from and Simmons responded the sources are coming from underground naturally. Chemin asked about VOC testing which Simmons said is being done frequently and the wells are secure. Simmons said the infrastructure debt has been accumulated to this point for service reliability and not removal of iron or manganese. Hoversten said when debt is retired it can be given back to lower the rate structure or pay for future needs and the tax levy is meant to build up capital reserve funds for City streets, parks and government operations. Kathleen Olesinski, 6230 Setter Circle, said the rates of manganese in the City water should be addressed in the newsletter going out to residents. Rodney Beystrom, 4466 Denbigh Road, stated he has been a resident of Mound since 1987 and hasn't had discoloration problems which he said is due to his use of water softeners. Greg Hainlen, 5542 Bartlett, asked for information on what type of water filter to buy. Steve Lynch, 3117 Highland Blvd., asked how much of his tax levy and how much of his utility bill goes to debt reduction. Hoversten said the utility fees base charges were reduced in 2019. Hoversten added that the typical utility bill is made up of 50% for sewer, water 40% and the remainder made up of recycling and storm sewer. Hoversten added that 60% of the utility costs go to the debt structure and 40% go to operations. Hoversten said the Property Tax Levy goes to Government operations and for areas such as Streets and Parks. Hoversten noted that the Street Projects are paid for through the tax levy, assessments, bonds and cash. Hoversten said water and sewer projects have separate funds which pay for those services. Hoversten added that the utility's 20-year bonds start to come off the books in 2025 through 2028. Hoversten said $70 Million in bonds were issued to cover those debts with $40 Million in outstanding debt left. Jackie Peipkorn, 4820 Canterbury Road, asked if the state determines the toxic level of manganese and Simmons responded the state has not determined if manganese is toxic or has a toxic level for it in its water standards but the City will continue to test and monitor levels in the drinking water supply. Peipkorn asked how long it has been a problem and Simmons said this is the first time it was tested for. Peipkorn asked if the chlorine levels added are monitored not to over treat and Simmons said absolutely it is monitored to ensure it is not too much or too little. Johann Chemin, 6039 Beachwood Road, said he went on vacation and when he came back and his hot water had black sediment and noted Simmons said that is how manganese manifests. Hoversten said draining the water softener is recommended and Chemin asked if it could be added to the advisory notice and Hoversten said the notice needs to focus on the advisory but that info on home water treatment and management is on the city website. Chemin said higher utilities will disenfranchise people. Hoversten agreed and said the balance between providing safe, affordable and reliable water is a difficult challenge. Mound City Council Minutes — March 9, 2021 Mayor Salazar thanked the speakers and Simmons and said the Council will look forward to the results of the study. 9. Information/Miscellaneous A. Comments/reports from Council Members/City Manager: Hoversten highlighted the following dates: March 16 Joint Special Meeting of the Planning Commission and City Council via ZOOM. March 23 CC Meeting will be held at the PAC April 13 CC Meeting may be held at the Council Chambers May 8 Mound Minnetrista City Clean Up Day Hoversten thanked all supporters of the Polar Plunge that was hosted this past Saturday and reminded the audience of the MN DOH Covid-19 Vaccine connector sign up as eligibility is opening up on Wednesday. Salazar once again thanked Simmons and Staff for the thorough presentation and thanked the City Council for staying ahead of the curve and supporting what is the right thing to do. B. Reports: Finance — January 2021 Fire — January 2021 Liquor Store — February 2021 C. Minutes: Planning Commission: 02-02-2021 Regular Meeting 10. Adiourn MOTION by Velsor, seconded by Larson, to adjourn at 9:49 p.m. All voted in favor. Motion carried. Mayor Raymond J. Salazar Attest: Catherine Pausche, Clerk